Friday, January 30, 2009

I am suspicious about the Investment deflator

This morning the BEA said that price of investment goods went up in Q4. This was especially true for nonresidential structures (7.4% annual inflation rate) and for equipment (3.4% annual inflation rate).

Their equipment inflation estimate may hold up -- the PPI for capital equipment went up every month of Q4.

I am dubious about the structures inflation. The PPI for construction went down every month this quarter. I would think that residential and nonresidential construction prices would move together. Fixing that could turn today's estimate of -3.8% per year GDP growth (for the quarter) into a revised -3.5%.

Wow I was close on Nominal GDP

Wow, in dollar terms, I was close on each of the spending categories (see below)!

I expected the GDP deflator to fall a lot more, and the experts thought it would rise. I wonder how much GDP deflator revision is possible.


Flashback: Q4 GDP deflators

The BEA released their deflators today:

GDP deflator: -0.3 percent (I had predicted -3.3 percent)
PCE deflator: -5.7 percent (I had predicted -4.6 percent)
GPDI deflator: +0.5 percent (I had predicted -0.8 percent)

My nominal GDP prediction was close -- it's just that I saw the GDP deflator falling more. The experts saw the GDP deflator going up.

Productivity Surges in Q4

From 2008 Q3 to 2008Q4, aggregate labor hours fell 7.4% (at an annual rate).

The BEA reported today that aggregate real GDP (that is, aggregate spending) fell only 3.8%.

That means:

  1. Productivity grew 3.6%, and

  2. We have to continue to question the common "wisdom" that spending drops are causing the employment drops. I tend to think that causes are bigger than effects: its the employment drop that causes the spending drop.


Flashback: GDP will not fall below $11 trillion

I promised that real GDP would not fall below $11 trillion (year 2000 chained). That is where real GDP was at the peak of the housing boom. If we stay above that floor, real GDP is doing better than the 1981-82 recession.

As you can see below, this morning's release of 2008 Q4 does not bring the $11 trillion mark much closer.


Wednesday, January 28, 2009

Fed Takes More Steps to Reduce Employment

I saw a report today that the Federal Reserve is taking still more steps to modify mortgages, and thereby reduce homeowners' incentive to work.

2008’s New Economic Highs Deeply Disappoint


When measured in terms of terms of financial gyrations and national employment, 2008 was an absolutely terrible year. When measured in terms of production, the U.S. economy in 2008 was the best in its history.

This week the Bureau of Economic Analysis will release its first estimate of Gross Domestic Product (G.D.P.) for the fourth quarter of 2008. G.D.P. measures the total amount produced and spent in the nation during a particular time frame, such as a year or a quarter-year. Some say that G.D.P. “is the best barometer of the country’s economic fitness.”

The first column of the table below shows GDP for the four quarters of 2007. 2007 United States G.D.P. was about $3,500 billion dollars for the United States in each quarter, for an annual total of $13,807 billion dollars. To put that more personal terms, the last rows of the table divide by the total population: 2007 G.D.P. was $45,776 per person.


One reason that more dollars can be spent in one year as compared to the previous year is that a dollar is worth less over time, but that by itself does not help American living standards. In order to compare 2008’s results to 2007’s in a way that is informative about living standards, most economists (including those at the B.E.A.) refer to real G.D.P.: dollar G.D.P. adjusted the effect of inflation.

The second column of the table therefore reports real G.D.P. for each quarter of 2008, measured using 2007 prices. That is, production for 2008 is measured using the items actually produced in 2008, but values each item at its 2007 price.

In each of the first three quarters of 2008, more was produced in our economy than was produced in the same quarter a year before. For example, G.D.P. in the third quarter (the months of July, August, and September) of 2008 was $26 billion more than in the same quarter of 2007.

We do not yet know what the B.E.A. will measure for the final quarter of 2008. Pundits such as the economic teams at Goldman Sachs or the Bush White House say that the growth rate of real G.D.P. from the third to fourth quarters will be about -5 percent per year, which means that they expect real G.D.P. for the fourth quarter will be 1.25 percent lower than it was in the third quarter: about $3,465 billion.

My estimates (detailed here) suggest that the B.E.A. will report fourth quarter real G.D.P. to be $3,503 billion – or about the same as in the third quarter. Despite our disagreement about Q4, the pundits and I agree that the annual total for 2008 will be about $14,000 billion, or very close to $46,000 per person. With real production of $46,000 per person, the “recession year” of 2008 produced more goods and services than did 2007, or any other year in U.S. history.

I have not seen any explanation of how the U.S. economy can reach new production highs at the same time that jobs disappear and its financial system is in chaos. But – given that the disease has such strange symptoms – I have to wonder whether the usual remedies are still appropriate.

Monday, January 26, 2009

Analysts Still Down on 2008 and 2009

"Many analysts predict the economy will have contracted at a pace of 5.4 percent in the fourth quarter when the government releases that report on Friday. If they are correct, that would mark the worst performance since a 6.4 percent drop in the first quarter of 1982."


Recall that my calculations for 2008 Q4 say -2.2, +0.4, and +0.8 (depending on the method) -- as compared to the -5.4 cited above.

Saturday, January 24, 2009

Supply Curves in "Slumdog Millionaire"

It is politically incorrect to suggest the supply of unemployed persons slopes up -- that an increase in payments to unemployed people will increase their numbers.

[warning: the laws of supply and demand sometimes reveal themselves in graphic and disgusting ways. You may not want to read what's below -- or see the film. The film is nominated for Oscars, so I assume that most of you already know about it]

Mysteriously, it is political correct -- fantastically popular, in fact -- to suggest that the supply of deformed children slopes up. "...hundreds of young children have had their arms and legs chopped off; scores of others have been blinded. The gangs also pour acid on to the children’s bodies, leaving them with suppurating wounds. A happy ending for the stars of the film Slumdog Millionaire - but for real slum dwellers the future is bleak. Their suffering comes down to one thing: money." (quote from here, but see the film yourself)

On the Relevance of Wartime Multipliers

Someone asked about the relevance of wartime multipliers. Just to be clear:

  1. I have written a lot about crowding out, and little of my analysis relies on wartime observations.
  2. It used to be said that the wartime spending pulled the U.S. out of Depression. Given that President Obama is telling us that he'll pull us out of recession, it is of some relevance that the wartime spending still crowded out private spending. Thus my link to Professor Barro who, incidentally, "wrote the book" on how government spending affects GDP.
  3. Even if it were true that the U.S. economy was at full employment before WWII began -- in which case it might not be a valid comparison to 2009 -- I have already directly addressed (in at least two different ways) -- the myth that the stimulus plans in Washington would actually utilize currently unemployed resources.
  4. Conspicuously absent from the commentary of those who claim that public spending would stimulate private spending are actual examples in which that actually occurred. [Admittedly, those economists (are there any besides Professor Krugman?) are vastly outnumbered and therefore need more time to put their case together]