Friday, January 23, 2009

Look Out U.S. Senate -- Here Comes Emma Alumn

Ms. Gillibrand was my wife's high school classmate at Emma Willard (she was called Kirsten Rutnick back then).

She blanketed a sprawling Congressional district in upstate NY to unseat the entrenched incumbent.

She voted against the Wall Street bailout.


British economy

I have not studied the British economy, and have no idea whether the specifics of their economics are similar to ours.

I noticed that their Q4 real growth rate was -6% per year, after being -2.5% per year in Q3, 0% per year in Q2, and +1.4% per year in Q1 (that is, their cumulative growth through Q3 had been -0.4% per year).

Our real growth rate through Q3 was +1.0% per year. Given that our economy was doing a lot better going into Q4, it seems that we should also do better in Q4.

CPI 1929 and 2008: Professor Nunes

Professor Nunes makes a compelling point about 1929 deflation: he says it came from reductions in the supply of money, whereas 2008 deflation (he says) came from relative price changes.

I think that 2008 deflation also came from a reduction in the supply of money -- relative to DEMAND. The supply of money did not fall in 2008, but the demand dramatically increased (the "flight to safety") and the Fed failed to fully accommodate it. It's the Fed's job to keep money supply in line with money demand. But read his document and let us know what you think.

Thursday, January 22, 2009

CPI in 1929 and 2008

It is Bernanke's job to promote price stability. How is he doing? Let's look at 1929 and 2008.

I have normalized Oct 1929 to be 100 (the stock market crashed at the end of that month) and Oct 2008 to be 100 (the stock market crashed at the beginning of that month).


Defenders of Bernanke can blame "falling commodity prices." That was the excuse in 1929, too. [In both 1929 and 2008, one could revise the CPI so that it excluded all items with falling prices, prove that the revised index did not fall, and thereby assign the blame for falling prices to the excluded items.]

Robert Barro Looks at Wartime "Multipliers"

Of course, they are less than one: public spending crowds out private spending.

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Stimulation isn't Everything



President Barack Obama expressed a vision for federal spending: that 2009 presents an opportunity for the federal government to invest in infrastructure, health care, and education sooner rather than later. Investments like these have intrinsic value — they are appealing because they are believed to serve the greater good — but not much stimulation potential.

When the government hires employees or makes purchases, their ultimate economic effect depends on what private sector activity is displaced.

In one scenario – called “crowding out” in economic jargon – some (but not necessarily all) of the new government employees are people who quit their private sector jobs in order to accept better positions offered by the public sector, and many (but not necessarily all) the new government purchases just take items that would have been purchased by a household or private business.

For example, an improvement of public schools may cause some students to withdraw from private schools and enroll in public ones and cause some school employees to relocate from private to public. The stimulus potential is minimal in this scenario, because much activity is shifting from private to public rather than being recreated anew. Gross domestic product may increase, but less than the public spending does – because public spending “crowds out,” or displaces, private spending.

Many people believe that moving students from private to public schools has intrinsic value. Or that building a public highway has intrinsic value even if it reduces private construction. Or that modernizing health care data has intrinsic value even if it reduces some other activity in technology industry. Thus, government purchases might be desirable even if they are not stimulating.

The second scenario is called the “multiplier.” In this view, government hiring and purchases largely acquire employees and resources that would have otherwise been idle. If this were correct, than the government’s spending in one area would not reduce spending in another. Instead, it would employ otherwise unemployed people, and get them spending again, thereby creating private spending on top of the government spending – hence the term “multiplier”. In the multiplier view, G.D.P. increases more than public spending.

Despite the recent increase in unemployment rates, I see little reason why the multiplier scenario is realistic. For example, President Obama’s economists have explained how about half of the jobs they plan to create (both directly and indirectly) are jobs for women. But the large majority of this recession’s employment reduction has been among men. Thus, the Obama spending plan is not designed to primarily draw on the pool of persons unemployed in this recession.

President Obama has a vision to spend more on health care, largely for its intrinsic value. Its stimulation value is minimal because unemployment is low in that sector; health sector employment has actually increased every single month during this recession.

Even the construction industry shows crowding out. The chart below shows two types of construction spending over time: residential and non-residential. The housing boom prior to 2006 clearly crowded out non-residential construction.



Perhaps there was not enough unemployment during the housing boom to realize the multiplier effect. But in the two-year period since the end of 2006 – the last twelve months of which have been an official recession – shows a similar pattern: Reduced spending in one area allows for more spending in another.

Significant publicity has been given to residential construction workers and equipment that became unemployed since 2006, but less recognized is the absorption of many (but by no means not all) of those resources by non-residential construction projects. Public spending on construction that might come from the President’s spending plan will re-employ so of those unemployed, but it will also draw others out of their current work activity. The latter is why crowding out will occur even in construction.

Government spending will reduce private spending virtually anywhere it may be targeted. The case for government spending should be made on its intrinsic, not stimulation, value.

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

The Consumption Spending Myth

FACT: Consumption spending is 2/3 of Total spending in the economy.

MYTH: If consumption spending falls, then it is likely that total spending falls.

Below is a graph of Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) and PCE + Net exports, for the months April 2008 - November 2008. Net exports is another form of spending in our economy (and thus included in the total): net spending by foreigners (that is, spending by foreigners in the U.S. minus spending by Americans abroad).




The PCE series repeats what the press has told us ad nauseum: consumption spending had been falling since June (longer in real terms).

"Net exports" is a small component of total spending, so it is tempting to ignore it. But the bottom series shows that (through Nov) the PCE decline has nevertheless been offset by increases in net exports. November PCE + net exports is higher than every month this year, except perhaps June (according to the BEA, June was a mere 0.04 percent higher than November).

PCE has fallen in large part because oil is cheaper. But oil production is not our major industry, which is why we continue to produce even while we do not continue to spend (as much).

Government spending (not shown) has increased throughout the year, so that investment is the only spending category that is unknown for Q4.

Monday, January 19, 2009

My Q4 GDP Forecast Details

The pundits (eg., Goldman Sachs or the White House) say that real GDP will fall about 5 percent (seasonally adjusted at annual rates) Q3-Q4.

I have used three different methods to make my own forecast, and each of them says that the pundits are wrong. Here is what I find for seasonally adjusted real GDP growth Q3-Q4 at annual percentage rates (and thus in the same units as the -5 cited above):
  • Productivity based: -2.2%
  • Income based: +0.4%
  • Spending based: +0.8%

The productivity forecast is the simplest: I take the -7.4 %/yr decline in aggregate work hours and assume that productivity rises via a movement up the labor demand curve, which yields -5.2%/yr. The pundits appear to stop here, assuming no productivity growth for a given amount of labor. But productivity has been increasing throughout this recession, so why should it stop now?! Thus I get -2.2%/yr.

The forecasts based on income and spending are shown in more detail below. In terms of the income account, the fairly strong aggregate payroll spending (as indicated by BEA and by Treasury payroll tax collections) are my reasons for optimism. In terms of the spending account, my optimism comes from net exports and my view that this recession's investment decline will be MILD.

I do not want to exaggerate the degree of precision any of us have -- the gap between my most and least optimistic forecast is only about $75 per person. The gap between Goldman and my least optimistic forecast is also about $75 per person. But there is no doubt that I see Q4 a lot differently than do the pundits.






Note: I have been saying for a while (e.g., here) that real GDP may well grow Q3 - Q4. All that is new today is that I have organized the details well enough to post here.

Quibbles with Cochrane

Neither Professor Cochrane nor I believe that public spending will raise private spending. Both of us hate to see the taxpayer get ripped off -- monumental ripoffs have occurred recently and more are on the horizon.

But I quibble with him about a few details:

Professor Cochrane writes "Every job created by stimulus spending is one job not created by the private spending it must displace."

I agree very much that crowding out is real. WWII is a nice example. For a 2008 example, look here or in my post this Wednesday.

But he is wrong to claim that crowding out has to be one for one. Again look at WWII -- yes GDP went up less than government spending, but it still went up. The adverse wealth effect of taxes is one mechanism by which it can happen. An intertemporal substitution effect is another.

Of course, the fact that public spending can increase GDP does not make it desirable! But let's get the positive analysis right.

Professor Cochrane writes "The only thing that matters is new debt, not who takes the hit for old bad debt"

It DOES matter who takes the hit for old debt: if the hit taken is a function of income, then debtors have little (in some cases, zero) incentive to work. I have noted this several times as relates to "mortgage modification" and tax debt forgiveness.

Also note that construction spending (including nonresidential) is higher in Q4 than it was in Q3. How does this happen if savings-investment intermediation is so terribly broken as Cochrane says?