Friday, January 16, 2009

Industrial Production 1929 and 2008


Here's an update through Dec 2008. Pessimistic interpretation: 2008 is 1/3 as bad as 1929. 1/3 of the Great Depression would not be good.

My Forecast for Q4 deflators

The Dec CPI came out today: down .7 percent (at monthly rates) from Nov. The Dec 2008 CPI is a bit lower than the Dec 2007 CPI: 2008 was a year of (a bit of) deflation.

This gives me enough data to make a confident forecast for the 2008 Q4 GDP deflators that will be released by BEA this month. The forecasts are Q3-Q4 percentage changes at annual rates.

GDP deflator: -3.3 percent
PCE deflator: -4.6 percent
GPDI deflator: -0.8 percent

Thursday, January 15, 2009

Flashback: Real Growth and Nominal Reduction

The PPI for Dec 2008 is lower than it was in Dec 2007. The CPI probably will probably finish 2008 like that too (tomorrow we'll know more). Thus, for the 12 months of 2008, prices fell overall even while real incomes increased. A rare phenomenon indeed!

[It is forecasted that 2008 Q4 real GDP will be lower than 2008 Q3. But nobody claims that real incomes in December 2008 were lower than real incomes in December 2007, because the economy was growing for the first half of 2008]

Deflation Continues, Bernanke is Shirking

Price stability (or a stable low inflation rate) is Bernanke's only job. Even if you think that Bernanke should dabble in other things (like popping bubbles or promoting full employment), you have to admit that price stability is his main responsibility.

The BLS announced today that producer prices decline for the fifth straight month (they fell almost 2 percent Nov-Dec alone). For Q4, that's a 5.5% decline (quarterly rates). The annual deflation rate Q3-Q4 is 20%. That's Great Depression style.

Remember that the various dollar figures we've heard (eg., that dollar retail sales dropped 2.7 percent Nov-Dec) need to be adjusted for price changes. I expect the CPI deflation to be a bit larger than PPI deflation, so the drop in retail sales volume is not as severe as the dollar drop. Indeed, the November to December change in retail sales VOLUME was likely less than one percent.

[if you are one of those who thinks that Bernanke is permitted to ignore certain price categories such as food and energy, notice how much the inflation rate for non-food-non-energy has dropped in the last six months. Bernanke needs to get to work.]

Wednesday, January 14, 2009

Data released today

Retail sales were released today. We still don't know whether the drop was in volume or in prices -- Dec price indices are coming out later this week.

I suspect that real quarterly retail sales are 5.5% lower in Q4 than in Q3. They were 2.5 percent lower in Q3 than in Q2.

But remember that retail sales are a lot more volatile than total consumption (the former are about 3% of the latter). I am working on my consumption forecast, but it will probably be around -1% (at a quarterly rate).

The other news today is that import prices fell more than export prices: good news for us, bad news for China and the middle east.

Are Recessions Still Manly?



The terrible bottom line of Friday’s job report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (B.L.S.) did not surprise many people – there were many fewer jobs in December 2008 than in the prior month.

Much less noticed, however, was Friday’s breakdown by sex of employment declines prior to December. Is it possible that one legacy of this recession is that women become a majority of the workforce for the first time in American history?

Years ago, women were a small minority of the workforce (outside the home). During much of the twentieth century – especially the 1970s and 1980s – women increased their share. By 1990, the workforce was 47 percent female and 53 percent male, according to the B.L.S. Many view this as one of the most important and desirable social and economic transformations of our lifetimes.

Until this recession, women throughout the 1990s and 2000s remained less than 49 percent of the workforce. However, that percentage has now passed 49 percent and may cross the 50 percent threshold for the first time.

In November 2008, the female workforce shrank more in percentage terms than it ever has in any one month – and more than ever over any single year – since 1964, if not longer. Nevertheless, female workforce reductions so far in this recession are smaller than those for the male workforce – even when measured in percentage terms – as has been the case in previous recessions.

The table below displays calculations for three recessions – 1990-91, 2001, and today. According to the National Bureau of Economic Research, the recessions began in July 1990, March 2001, and December 2007, respectively. The first two ended in March 1991 and November 2001. Two notes: First, nobody knows when this recession will end, and second, the most recent data for which the B.L.S. reports employment by sex is November 2008.



During the first recession, male employment fell by 2.0 percent, while female employment hardly fell at all (less than 0.05 percent). In the other two recessions, the percentage employment loss for men exceeded that for women by a factor of 3 to 5 (interestingly, although women still have a small minority of each recession’s employment decline, the female share of the decline has increased from one recession to the next, indicating that women’s jobs have become more sensitive to changes in the business cycle).

The bottom of the table shows how, as a result of the larger male jobs losses, recessions have increased women’s percentage of the work force by about 0.5 in recent recessions. For example, the 0.5 percentage point increase that occurred in the eight months of the 1990-91 recession is more than occurred for the ten years that followed, or in the six years that followed the 2001 recession.

If the pundits are right that this recession will be long and severe, then women may gain the 0.9 percentage points from November 2008 that would push them past the 50 percent milestone. Important milestones will remain to be achieved, but women’s surpassing 50 percent of employment is something that historians will note for years to come.

Real Growth and Nominal Reduction?

The BEA has quarterly national accounts back to 1947. During that time (62 years), nominal GDP NEVER fell while real GDP grew, even for a single quarter.

The BEA has annual national accounts back to 1929. During that time, nominal GDP NEVER fell while real GDP grew. Judging from the annual rates, it's possible that it happened for a quarter during 1933 or 1938.

[The BEA has monthly consumption back to 1959, during that time (599 months) nominal consumption fell while real consumption grew only two or three times: Nov 2008, Sep 2006, and maybe Dec 2001 (real consumption was essentially constant here)].

But it may have happened in 2008 Q4! Even I am confident that nominal GDP fell in Q4. But I have noted the significant (but still less than one half) probability real GDP grows in Q4.

Milton Friedman mentioned that it happened several times in history prior to the Great Depression -- does anyone have that reference? I suspect it is in his AEA presidential address, but maybe in the Monetary History.

[update (via Tino): p. 97 of the Monetary History says "From 1891 to 1896 net national product in current prices fell at an average rate of roughly 1 per cent per year, and in constant prices rose at a rate of roughly 2 per cent per year." Chart 16 seems to show some real income growth 1927-27, but a money income decline.]

Tuesday, January 13, 2009

Payroll Tax Revenues Keep Rolling in Q4

One indicator of labor market activity is the collection of payroll tax revenue by the U.S. Treasury, released today through the end of calendar year 2008. This has an advantage over other measures because it is comprehensive -- it counts all the dollars rather than just gathering a sample of employers. It is also a high stakes measure -- an employer has no reason to tell the Treasury that he is paying employees -- and then pay tax for them -- when in fact he is not.

A disadvantage is that Treasury collections are not seasonally adjusted, and can fluctuate due to quirks in the tax rules. For that reason, I focus on payroll tax collections for "Employment and General Retirement" because the rules for those are pretty simple as compared to the rules for individual income tax or corporate income tax.

Payroll tax revenue in Q4 (Oct, Nov, Dec) was $213.67 billion, as compared to $202.024 billion in Q3. That's an increase of 5.6% (at a quarterly rate)!

Note that, in the couple of years prior to 2008, payroll tax revenue fell a bit Q3-Q4 (in part, I suspect, because some workers go over the payroll tax gap in Q4). Thus, I suspect that seasonally adjusted payroll tax revenue growth Q3-Q4 would be even higher than 5.6%.

Another Reason Why Q4 GDP growth might not be so bad

Recall that GDP is the sum of spending on private consumption, private investment, government consumption and investment, and net exports.

The November trade report came out today, and suggests that Q4 net exports will improve about $50 billion (at quarterly rates).

How big is $50 billion? Well, GDP for 2008 Q3 was about $3600 trillion. Forecasters have been saying that GDP will fall at a 5 percent annual rate, which means that it will fall 5/4 of a percent from Q3 to Q4. 0.05*3600/4 = $45 billion.

Yes, you read that correctly -- the change in net exports (in the direction of raising GDP) is as large as the declines that the forecasters think they see.

We need to be careful because, in principle, an increase in net exports could just reflect a reduction in consumption (and thereby no change in the sum of consumption and net exports). This quarter, much of the trade deficit improvement is reduced oil imports. However, that is not a reduction in real consumption but rather a reflection of improved terms of trade (oil prices have dropped a lot more than the prices of goods we export).

I will soon finish my spending-based and income-based real GDP growth forecasts. I explained earlier that my employment based forecast is -2.5% (at annual rates). I expect the spending-based forecast to be at least as optimistic, and the income-based forecast to be the most optimistic of the three.

Monday, January 12, 2009

More Exaggeration of Great Depression Parallels

Obama's choice for CEA chair draws parallels with the Great Depression. She says: the economy got out of hand after the 1929 financial panic, and we should not let the same happen now.

But is today's economy -- so far without any "help" from the Obama administration -- following the same path? Below is the Federal Reserve's monthly Industrial Production Index (which also existed in 1929). I have normalized Oct 1929 to be 100 (the stock market crashed at the end of that month) and Oct 2008 to be 100 (the stock market crashed at the beginning of that month). One thing we notice is that, after the summer 1929, it was a long time until the index increased again (the first increase is off the scale -- in early 1931). In 2008, the index did not increase again until ... um ... October.


As in 1929, the industrial production index fell 4 or 5 percent PRIOR to the 2008 crash. In 1929, the index fell 5 percent in November after falling 2 percent in October. In 2008, the index fell 0.7 percent in November after rising 1.4 percent in October.

2008 looks different to me. On Friday the Fed will release December 2008 Industrial Production, and we can see how close it gets to the 1929 time series.