Monday, January 12, 2009

Nonexistent WMD V: Industrial production and Capacity Utilization

After Lehman failed and “credit markets froze” in the second half of September 2008, many people proclaimed that a second Great Depression would unfold. A few days ago, I explained how payrolls did not collapse as some had been predicting in late September and early October.

During the first days of October 2008, it was claimed that the frozen credit markets would especially paralyze businesses. Now that a couple of months have passed, let’s look at industrial production and capacity utilization (two measures of business activity that are available monthly) as measured by the Federal Reserve. The charts below show industrial production (measured as a index) and capacity utilization (measured as a percentage of full capacity) for each of the months of second half of 2008 (December data not yet available). Both fell in and again in September, and have remained higher than September in the months since.




The Lehman Brothers investment bank failed on September 15. The bank was deeply intertwined with other financial institutions – its failure to pay its obligations put its creditors at risk – and brought the credit crisis to its crescendo. By the end of the month, the intense financial chaos motivated Mr. Obama and others to warn that banks needed lots of money from taxpayers, or else businesses and consumers would get hammered. Because the bailout bill took time to pass, and then additional time for the Treasury to design and execute its $700 billion Capital Purchase Program (CPP), no bank received any money from the Treasury pursuant to the CPP until the last couple of days of October. Thus, if the warnings were right, business production should have suffered dramatically in October.

Industrial production and capacity utilization may put too much emphasis on manufacturing and thereby give a noisy picture of the overall economy, but we were promised disastrous results -- and thus results that would be obvious even in noisy data.

Politicians from both parties alarmed the American public at the end of September and in early October in order to justify spending $700 billion of taxpayer funds on a bailout of United States banks. I previously showed three measures of October and November activity that were by no means disastrous by comparison to previous months. Above are two more.

Sunday, January 11, 2009

Economic Numbers Coming out this Week

In the order of importance in my analysis:

  1. Dec real earnings (BLS, Fri)
  2. Dec Advance Retail Sales (Census Bureau, Wed)
  3. Dec PPI (BLS, Thurs)
  4. Dec CPI (BLS, Fri)
  5. Industrial Production (Fed, Fri)
  6. Nov International Trade (BEA, Tues)
  7. JOLT (BLS, Tues)

The Federal Reserve Bank of NY has a nice calendar.

Nonexistent WMD IV: Others are Calling it the "Great Hoax of 2008"

I wish I had thought of that!

These guys (here and here) have updated the banking data that I and Chari and Christiano and Kehoe had looked at back in October. The update fails to show an obvious footprint of a credit crunch.

Nonexistent WMD III: Small Business Income in October

After Lehman failed and “credit markets froze” in the second half of September 2008, many people proclaimed that a second Great Depression would unfold. A few days ago, I explained how payrolls did not collapse as some had been predicting in late September and early October.

During the first days of October 2008, it was claimed that the frozen credit markets would especially paralyze small businesses. Now that a couple of months have passed, let’s look at proprietor's income (a measure of small business activity) as measured by the Bureau of Economic Analysis. The chart below shows proprietor's income (measured in billions of dollars) for each of the months of second half of 2008 (December data not yet available). Aggregate proprietor's income fell in August. It fell about 0.5 percent in September, and has remained within 0.2 percent of that ever since.



The Lehman Brothers investment bank failed on September 15. The bank was deeply intertwined with other financial institutions – its failure to pay its obligations put its creditors at risk – and brought the credit crisis to its crescendo. By the end of the month, the intense financial chaos motivated Mr. Obama and others to warn that banks needed lots of money from taxpayers, or else small businesses would get hammered. Because the bailout bill took time to pass, and then additional time for the Treasury to design and execute its $700 billion Capital Purchase Program (CPP), no bank received any money from the Treasury pursuant to the CPP until the last couple of days of October. Thus, if the warnings were right, small business should have suffered dramatically in October.

Proprietor's income is a notoriously noisy measure, but we were promised a large collapse -- and thus one that would be obvious even in noisy data.

None of the above denies or confirms that our economy is headed for economic depression, because there are multiple pathways for getting there. Nor does it deny that the Treasury CPP might help in some way. But it does refute one of the scariest pathways to Depression – an immediate collapse of small business – that politicians from both parties alarmingly described to the American public in order to justify spending $700 billion of taxpayer funds on a bailout of United States banks.

Saturday, January 10, 2009

Obama team will not fix tough times for men

Male employment has fallen 1.8 million so far during this recession. If Obama is right that the economy will get worse before it gets better, we should expect that, sometime in the next few months, male employment will be down a total of 2.5 million (men lost 350,000 jobs in November 2008 alone).

Female employment is down much less (see my post next Wednesday).

The Obama team today released parts of a plan to save the economy and boost employment (they claim) 3.7 million by 2010 Q4 (almost 2 years from now), of which 2.1 million will be male employment.

The 3.7 million grossly exaggerates what government can do, but I am going to take their calculations literally for the moment. They are saying that male employment will still be down about 400,000 two years from now, whereas female employment will be a million higher than it was when the recession started.

Assuming that sex changes are not part of the fiscal stimulus plan (of course, they are not!), the Obama team admits that it intends to put to work a very different group of people than were working a year ago.

One defense of that part of the Obama plan is that the income matters -- it does not matter who earns it. I tend to subscribe to this view, but it implies that we should be looking at GDP and not employment.

If employment matters per se -- that is, public policy should "fix" low employment even if GDP were doing fine, then I do not see how the Obama team can defend putting people to work who were not working a year ago, and allowing those who worked a year ago to remain without jobs.

[added: a standard measure of employment is "payroll employment" -- that is, the number of positions on businesses' payrolls. Each position is either held by a man or a woman, so the "male employment" I described above is just the number of positions held by men. It does NOT refer to the number of occupations that are "male dominated", but rather to positions actually held by men. For example, some of the male employment is in nursing because some men are paid to work as nurses. Some of the female employment is in construction, because some women are paid to do construction work.]

January 30 will be a political and economic milestone

The BEA releases its advance estimate of 2008 Q4 real GDP on January 30. There is a chance (admittedly, less than 50%) that it will show that real GDP was HIGHER in Q4 than in Q3.

If so, the release will unleash a huge political and economic debate. Washington will be in the middle of the preparation of a massive stimulus package. The employment numbers (December employment is released Jan 9) will undoubtedly help the case for stimulus, but real GDP growth would make a great case against. How can we justifying a huge spending bill if GDP were seen to grow without it?

Friday, January 9, 2009

Review of My Forecasts

I have a number of forecasts. Most of them have already been shown to be true. The remainder need more time until the data needed to verify them are released.

The purpose of this post is to reiterate the forecasts and their economic or statistical basis, prior to the jobs report that is coming out in a few hours.
  1. real GDP will exceed 6 percent of its value at the time of the housing crash, sometime during 2009 or 2010. By comparison, private consumption will not increase as much.
  2. between now and then, real GDP will not fall below $11 trillion (year 2000 chained)
  3. between now and then, nonfarm payroll employment will not fall below 134 million.>

The basis for these 3: investment can continue even while banks are in a mess (see my nytimes piece in Oct).


(1) is not a short term prediction, because this basis does not say exactly how long it takes other sectors to absorb former construction and bank employees. (2) and (3) are both short and long term predictions.

If one of these turns out to be wrong, but investment remains strong then we will all be puzzled because it was the banks who were supposed to bring disaster through an investment collapse. But in this case I will admit that I neglected some very fundamental factors.

(4) housing construction will resume my summer 2009.

(4) is based on the combination of my view of the banking system (that it is able to make housing loans as soon as it makes economic sense to build houses) AND my estimate of the pre-"bubble" trend for housing demand. If I were wrong about the latter, then housing construction would resume later for reasons having nothing to do with banks. One way to confirm this interpretation versus others is to look at housing rents -- if they get high then I'll admit that banks are holding back supply.

(5) real GDP may grow Q3-Q4 less than -5 percent (annualized), but it is just as likely to grow more than zero.

(5) is NOT based on my hypotheses about the banking system. It is based on two things: (a) my view that productivity and employment move in opposite directions in this recession (this view has little to do with my view of banking and investment), which makes me a little more optimistic Q3-Q4 than the consensus forecast, and (b) my statistical analysis of October and November (all that I have right now) national income items. Thus, if (5) is wrong, it is because my productivity forecast was wrong or because the December data was dramatically different than Oct-Nov or because the national income accounts' "statistical discrepancy" (an official item) were large relative to the gap between my forecast and others'. The result of (5), and the reasons for it, will be known Jan 30, 2009.

Thursday, January 8, 2009

Federal Government Taking Steps on Mortgage Modification

Obama's stimulus package will likely allow "bankruptcy judges alter home loans in an effort to prevent foreclosures and urged other lenders to follow suit." (read more here)

This will likely encourage banks to follow the Streamlined Modification Program before a mortgage gets on a judge's desk. But I don't know the details or how judges would modify -- could there be some way this move reduces the now massive implicit tax from mortgage modification?

Wednesday, January 7, 2009

Flashback: Another Example of How Washington Helped Decapitalize the Banking Industry

A billionaire venture capitalist explains how he has not yet bought a distressed bank because the Treasury is doing all the buying these days.

Thanks Alberto for the tip.

October Hysteria in Hindsight


After Lehman failed and “credit markets froze” in the second half of September 2008, many people proclaimed that a second Great Depression would unfold. In hindsight, we readily see that at least one of the purported pathways to depression was never followed.

During the first days of October 2008, it was claimed that businesses would not be able to borrow from banks even for basic operational expenses, such as making their payrolls. As employees had to work without pay (so the story goes), the businesses patronized by those employees would suffer, and the downward spiral would continue. Then presidential-candidate Barack Obama said that “the credit market is seized up and businesses, for instance, can't get loans to meet payroll.” It was even suggested that “recession proof” employers such as colleges and municipalities would not be able to pay their employees.

Now that a couple of months have passed, let’s look at payroll spending measured by the Bureau of Economic Analysis. The chart below shows payroll spending (measured in billions of dollars) for each of the months of second half of 2008 (December data not yet available), including contributions to pension and health funds for employees. Aggregate payroll spending was highest in August, and has remained within 0.1 percent of the August high ever since.



The Lehman Brothers investment bank failed on September 15. The bank was deeply intertwined with other financial institutions – its failure to pay its obligations put its creditors at risk – and brought the credit crisis to its crescendo. By the end of the month, the intense financial chaos motivated Mr. Obama and others to warn that banks needed lots of money from taxpayers, or else the banks’ business customers would not be able to pay their employees.

Because the bailout bill took time to pass, and then additional time for the Treasury to design and execute its $700 billion Capital Purchase Program (CPP), no bank received any money from the Treasury pursuant to the CPP until the last couple of days of October. Thus, if the warnings were right, payroll spending should have been precipitously lower in October than in the previous months. Instead, payroll spending was almost $1 billion dollars higher in October than in September – not exactly the collapse that we feared.

Some of the details of the CPP became known earlier in October. Anticipation of the CPP expenditures cannot explain why payroll spending did not collapse in October, because the purported pathway to depression was about the day-to-day cash needs of otherwise strong businesses. Even the United States Treasury admitted last week that “capital [from its CPP] needs to get into the system before it can have the desired effect.”

Even when some (but by no means all) of the CPP funds finally got “into the system” in the last days of October and the full month of November, Congress was dismayed to see that banks were not using the funds to lend. Nevertheless, payroll spending did not collapse in November, either.

It is true that payroll employment fell by about 850,000 in October and November – and that’s serious as compared to the last couple of recessions – but the payroll spending data show that the employment loss was small compared to the spending collapse forecasted in early October. The fact is that more than 136,000,000 workers received their paychecks – more than $1.3 trillion worth in October and November combined – essentially the same aggregate payroll that was paid out in the two months prior to Obama’s warning.

None of the above denies or confirms that our economy is headed for economic depression, because there are multiple pathways for getting there. Nor does it deny that the Treasury CPP might help in some way. But it does refute one of the scariest pathways to Depression – a collapse of payroll spending – that politicians from both parties alarmingly described to the American public in order to justify spending $700 billion of taxpayer funds on a bailout of United States banks.