Wednesday, January 7, 2009
The Marginal Tax Rate Hike of 2009
I interrupt WMD week to announce the marginal tax rate hike of 2009:
AP reports "As the nation sinks deeper into recession, the IRS is offering to waive late penalties, negotiate new payment plans and postpone asset seizures for delinquent taxpayers who are financially strapped, but make a good-faith effort to settle their tax debts. ...those seeking help will have to demonstrate their inability to pay." [see also this report]
I explained in a number of previous posts (here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and here) how when mortgage debt collectors offer forgiveness, but only for persons with incomes that are low in comparison with their debts, that creates financial disincentives for working.
You might guess that the economics is much the same for tax debt collectors: when they offer forgiveness, but only for persons with incomes that are low in comparison with their debts, that creates financial disincentives for working. That's why I call that new IRS policy a marginal tax rate hike.
Labels:
fiscal policy,
labor market
Tuesday, January 6, 2009
Labor Supply and Demand: Today and in the Great Depression
Figure 15 (from my new paper "What Caused the 2008 Recession? Hints from Labor Productivity") is a scatter plot contrasting this recession and previous ones along these dimensions. Each recession is one data point in the chart. The horizontal axis measures the change in the log productivity residual from one quarter prior to the NBER peak to the fourth quarter following the NBER peak. The vertical axis measures the change in the unmeasured labor distortion (also in log points). The first three recessions each had productivity shifts that were less than experienced during non-recession years. The 2008 recession is unusual in that it has normal productivity shifts (so far) throughout the recession, but the largest adverse labor distortion shock. The 1970s and 1980s had less increase in the labor distortion than did the other recessions.

The Great Depression of the 1930s (not shown in the Figure) is qualitatively like the 1970s recession, but multiplied many times. Cole and Ohanian (1999, Table 6) find total factor productivity to fall five percent in the first year of the Great Depression, and a total of 14 percent through four years. Mulligan (2005, Figure 4) finds the Great Depression labor supply distortion to increase 0.17 log points in the first year and 0.46 log points through four years.
In other words, 1929-30 would be in the same quadrant of Figure 15 as the 1970s recession, and on about the same ray from the origin, but five times further away. 1929-33 would be about 15 times further.
Labels:
1930s comparison,
labor market,
productivity
Monday, January 5, 2009
Construction spending so far higher in Q4 than in Q3
- November construction spending averaged $89.9 billion.
- October construction spending averaged $90.4 billion.
- Q3 monthly construction spending averaged $89.9 billion.
It seems to me that Q4 may well finish with more NOMINAL construction spending than Q3. Construction is also cheaper in Q4 than in Q3 --> more REAL construction in Q4 than in Q3.
Can someone explain to me where I can see this fall's credit crisis depress real aggregate activity? I don't see it in real payrolls (more on that Wednesday), real proprietor's income (more on that Thursday), or real construction spending.
The whole justification of the $700 billion bailout reminds me of the supposed WMD in Iraq -- scary but nonexistent. A payoll collapse, small business collapse, and construction collapse were somehow all prevented without the $700 billion.
Labels:
bailout,
banking crisis,
housing market,
public policy myths
WMD week
This week is my blog's WMD week. More accurately, it is politicians-said-there-are-WMDs-but-in-reality-there-are-none week.
President Bush said there were WMDs in Iraq, but nobody was able to find them.
President Bush, Presidential-candidate Obama, and several other Democratic party Senators, said on October 1 that an economic collapse was imminent unless the U.S. Treasury took $700 billion of our tax dollars and gave it to U.S. banks. The Bush administration and Congressional Democrats appealed to the same fears to rationalize giving several billion to the auto industry.
This week I will scour the economic data for October and November and try desperately to find those economic-WMDs. You will see that I won't even find a squirt gun!
Labels:
bailout,
banking crisis,
public policy myths
Another Reason why Q4 GDP Just Might Increase
I admit that positive real GDP growth is an underdog. But here's another case for it:
- Prices have fallen 1-2% since Q3. Thus, nominal GDP has to fall at least 1% if real GDP is going to fall.
- Nominal compensation of employees and proprietor's income (at annual rates) is at least as high in Oct & Nov as in Q3. (The well publicized employment reduction should work through this item).
- Depreciation must be at least as high in Q4 as in Q3, because investment hasn't stopped.
- All of the above means that capital income has to fall at least $144 billion (at annual rates) Q3 to Q4 in order to make real GDP shrink Q3-Q4.
- $144 billion capital income reduction would far exceed the cumulative reduction in capital income since the beginning of this recession.
- $144 billion capital income reduction would increase labor's share to 0.683 from 0.659 a year earlier -- matching the largest YOY increase in labor's share since WWII.
Labels:
economic outlook
Flashback: Nonresidential Investment Boom
I have consistently explained (eg., here and here) how the housing boom was diverting resources away from nonresidential investment. Once the boom was over, it became time to invest in the nonresidential sector again.
I was told that the latter couldn't happen, because banks were (supposedly) not lending.
Well, November showed yet another INCREASE in nonresidential construction spending:
"The Commerce Department reported Monday that construction spending dropped by 0.6 percent in November, less than half of the 1.3 percent decline economists expected. A 4.2 percent fall in housing construction was partially offset by a surprisingly strong 0.7 percent rise in nonresidential activity."
This was no surprise to readers of this blog!!
Construction spending is measured in dollars -- so it is an even bigger real increase (recall that investment goods prices have been falling these days).
Labels:
economic outlook,
housing market
Flashback: The Rhetorical Gap far Exceeds the Policy Gap
Before the election I blogged a couple of times (here and here) about how Democrats and Republicans talk so differently about public policy, but ultimately execute so similarly.
Since then, I noted how quickly President-elect and Democrat Obama withdrew is plans to repeal the Bush tax cut.
Now we learn that:
- President-elect Obama plans to cut taxes MORE than Bush did!
- President-elect Obama's Mideast stance may not be so different than we were led to believe. "Arab commentators and editorialists say there is growing disappointment at Obama's detachment - and that his failure to distance himself from George Bush's strongly pro-Israeli stance is encouraging the belief that he either shares Bush's bias or simply does not care."
You might say events have changed significantly since Nov 4, and these events coincidentally caused President-elect Obama to act more Republican. What events, exactly? Are we more worried about the economy now than we were in October (remember that's the month when we decided to give away $700 billion to banks)? Is it brand new that Israel has violent encounters with Hamas?
And why does coincidence perennially push in the directions of causing Democrats to act more Republican and Republicans to act more Democratic?
Saturday, January 3, 2009
The Economic Content of Politically Correct Business Cycle Analysis
- An economic tautology says that all market fluctuations are explained by some combination of preferences, technologies, and market distortions.
- A recession is defined (by NBER) to be a reduction in the quantity of employment.
- It is political incorrect to blame a significant part of recession on a reduced preference for working.
From these three, basic logic implies that either (a) the preference for working never falls, or (b) that it falls only at times when it is fully compensated by demand increases (that it, it only falls during non-recessions).
(b) seems like a remarkable coincidence, so we must conclude that the preference for working never falls.
Moreover, given that the preference for working never falls, the same logic implies that the preference for working never increases, or else (after 1000s of years of the human race) all we would do is work.
Political correctness makes labor market analysis easy -- we only have to study demand and distortions; supply can (and must) be ignored!
I really should stop fighting the utter neglect of supply, and instead appreciate its productive value.
Labels:
labor market
Friday, January 2, 2009
Housing Price Changes this Fall -- Maybe Bad News for Banks
Case and Shiller released their October housing price index on Dec 30. It is a 3-month moving average (that is, the October value uses housing prices from Aug, Sept, Oct).
The Oct value of the index is 2.0% below the Sept value, which was itself 2.0% below the Aug value. As I predicted a couple of months ago, housing prices continue to fall. They will fall (and housing construction will continue to be essentially nil) until they are near construction costs. This should happen this summer.
Obviously, housing prices and construction costs can come into line in two ways: housing prices fall further, or construction costs rise. Construction costs stopped rising in October -- the October PPI for residential construction was actually 1.2% lower than for September. November's was another 1.3% lower than that. Unless we get some significant inflation in the very near future, it looks like owners of mortgages are going to see their loans decline further in value because falling construction costs are yet another force pulling down the value of their collateral.
A silver lining for banks is perhaps that markets already had anticipated some construction cost declines.
disclusure: long XLF
Labels:
housing market
Thursday, January 1, 2009
Fundamental Inconsistencies in the Treasury's Report to Congress
Yesterday the U.S. Treasury reported to Congress about its $700 billion bailout program, which it now calls the "Capital Purchase Program."
It claims that the program helped "prevent a financial collapse" (p. 4). At the same time, it admits that “capital [from its CPP] needs to get into the system before it can have the desired effect.” (p. 5)
I find these claims to be fundamentally inconsistent, because (a) most of the CPP money has not yet been received by the banking system and (b) NONE of it had been received as of October 27. How did we survive between September 15 (when Lehman failed and brought on the crescendo of the credit crisis) and October 27? How did businesses make payrolls?
Maybe some credit goes to the Federal Reserve, who (from a different authority) was spending taxpayer dollars throughout September and October. But the whole justification of the $700 billion TREASURY authority reminds me of the supposed WMD in Iraq -- scary but nonexistent. A financial collapse was somehow prevented without the $700 billion.
Labels:
bailout,
banking crisis
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)