Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Real Estate Crisis? It Depends on Supply

Copyright, The New York Times Company

Real estate’s future can often be understood by closely watching the supply of residential and commercial buildings.

In early 2009, employment and gross domestic product were dropping sharply, and real estate values had plummeted from their highs in 2006. The housing market was already in crisis, so it felt right to expect the commercial real estate market to follow.

Nouriel Roubini predicted, “More than 700 banks could fail as a result of their exposure to commercial real estate.” Elizabeth Warren later reported, “There is a commercial real estate crisis on the horizon.”

And journalists frequently referred to a looming commercial real estate crisis.

But none of this commentary noted how the supply situation in commercial real estate was drastically different than it was in housing.

By 2008, it was clear that too many homes were built for the market to bear. But the four-to-five-year boom in housing construction had taken resources away from commercial building, holding down the inventory of structures that would be available for business use.

With commercial structures in relatively short supply, I concluded in early 2009 that there would probably not be a commercial real estate crisis creating waves of bank failures.

My conclusion was greeted with much skepticism (one example was Salon’s article on “The NYT’s Chicago Economist: Wrong Again,” insisting that warning of a commercial real estate meltdown was part of “reliable economy-watching”). Paul Krugman also weighed in.

More than two years have passed, and we no longer hear much about the once-imminent crisis.

Professor Roubini still thinks that a commercial real estate crisis is ahead. Others said the crisis was averted. Either way, it is now recognized that the relatively low supply of commercial real estate made a big difference.

In order to assess the likelihood that the housing sector double dips – that is, has another crisis something like the one in 2008 – it helps to look at the supply.

The black line in the chart below shows an index of housing inventory per person at the end of each year from 1990 to 2011 (with housing inventory measured as square footage, adjusted for quality; 2011 is a forecast). Housing supply almost always increases faster than population, but the housing boom of 2002-6 stood out compared with the other years in terms of the relative rate of housing construction.

By 2007, housing supply was well above the trend of the 1990s (before the housing boom). If you think that a rational market would have more or less followed that 1990s trend, then the excess supply in 2007 meant that housing prices had to come down.

Of course, housing prices did come down a lot in 2007 and 2008, and the housing supply stopped growing. By the end of 2010 – the second-to-last observation shown in the chart – housing supply had fully returned to the trend of the 1990s.

Because the pace of housing construction continues to be slow, it looks as if housing supply will be significantly below trend by the end of this year.

These supply results tell us something about the future of housing prices. Those prices depend on demand, too, but as long as housing demand is near or above the preboom trend, it looks as though housing prices are low enough already.

Part of the inventories of housing and commercial property sit vacant, but those vacancies are largely part of a slow economic recovery and the difficult task of dividing property losses from previous years among homeowners, landlords, banks and commercial tenants.

With the slow pace of new construction, neither the housing nor commercial real estate markets can any longer be characterized as having supply that significantly exceeds the fundamentals of demand.


Griya Mobil Kita said...

Nice article, thanks for the information.
sewa mobil

Unknown said...

Thats a pretty good article, i agree..some still reviving and others have stable status

Peter Kelly
Commercial Property Botany

lakecrossing said...

I just wanted to add a comment here to mention thanks for you very nice ideas. Blogs are troublesome to run and time consuming thus I appreciate when I see well written material. Your time isn’t going to waste with your posts. Thanks so much and stick with it No doubt you will definitely reach your goals! have a great day!

apartments in gainesville

lakecrossing said...

Interesting and important information. It is really beneficial for us. Thanks

apartment Gainesville

villavalenciacondos said...

I just couldn’t leave your website before telling you that we really enjoyed the quality information you offer to your visitors… Will be back often to check up on new posts.

apartment in gainesville

Unknown said...

Real estate crisis well, I agree does depends on the supply - but it is only one of those many factors that we can come up to why the industry is in bad condition - and feels like becoming worst. In a Louisiana real estate school, some classes do provide in depth understanding of the probable reasons why the current market is falling, and how to at least improve or pick it up back.

homes salechicago said...

Very good points you wrote about this .. Great stuff ... I think you've done some really interesting points.Keep a good job.
homes for short sale in chicago

moco said...

I absolutely love reading this article, the manner of writing is outstanding.This post as usual was instructive, I have had to bookmark your website and subscribe to this feed in googlereader. this site looks impressive.
mesin fotocopy| rental sound | rumah dijual | perlengkapan bayi | SEO Company | party organizer | parfum

butoijoh said...

My hope is that some members of jakarta hotel our community will be interested in submitting their scholarly work for possible presentation at the conference. I'm serving as co-ch air of the conference's Marketing Education track, one of more than 15 tracks that comprise the conference program.

Unknown said...

Hmmm.....Great idea your write article.
thanks blogger,

toko online | Grosir Kaos

Yasir said...

Because their customers are devoting some sources to pay for the system. bubblegum casting

butoijoh said...

Nice article! Keep update!

Jasa SEO

Unknown said...

Please visit :
Toko Bunga