Wednesday, January 9, 2013

What Does "Health Insurance Cost" Mean?

Beginning next year, people without health insurance through their employer will be able to buy it monthly on "exchanges." They are encouraged to buy the insurance, or else face a penalty for each month and family member not covered. Let's suppose for the moment that the penalty is enforced (even though law limits how the IRS can enforce it).

By law, people can let their insurance lapse for three months with no penalty. Moreover, they can choose when the three month lapse occurs, and accelerate and/or delay medical procedures to fall outside the lapse interval, without concern for being denied when they restart insurance because of "pre-existing conditions."

Arguably, essentially everyone without employer health insurance would find it in his interest to purchase insurance for only 9 months per year, and cram all of their medical procedures into the nine months of their choosing. Medicaid already experiences this phenomenon (namely people enroll if and when they get sick), and Medicaid participants do not pay premiums.  Exchange participants will be paying really money.

There is no free lunch in the aggregate, so insurance companies will have to increase their monthly premiums by 12/9 so that they collect the same annual revenue from participants. When this happens, do we say that health insurance costs went up by 33 percent? Or that they were constant?

If you chose the latter, then you are saying that health insurance costs should be measured by premiums per person, where "persons" denominator includes people who are not currently insured. But then the historical trend for health insurance costs should be measured the same way, and would be less steep due to the fact that uninsurance rates have increased over time.

Another problem with choosing the latter is that exchange participants (suckers?) who do not play this game -- they pay their premium all 12 months of the year -- will pay more for health insurance on both a monthly and an annual basis.

Both proponents and opponents of the ACA will want to know whether the new law fulfilled its promise of "bending the cost curve," but my guess is that an army of economists will be needed merely to do the measurement -- to measure health insurance costs before and after 1/1/2014 in ways that are comparable.


ElMadster said...

"What Does "Health Insurance Cost" Mean?" It means TOTAL AGGREGATE USA HC COSTS.

>> "an army of economists will be needed merely to do the measurement"

Actually, this will be easier than anyone imagines. Total up ALL HC expenditures (Govt, Private, OTC) and compare to the previous year (or decade). Except for OTC, these costs are easily available.

Despite, spin to the contrary there is very little in OC to reduce costs, and much to increase them.

So, the costs of OC will be staggering but the misinformation will be even more staggering. Fortunately, anyone with an internet connection and a spreadsheet will be able to do the cost-comparison math

Marc Sargen said...

Their may be some increase in health insurance due to people trying to time expenses but overall it will not be huge. Try to suspend & turn on is a huge timing issue & a lot of bureaucratic work. Most people will go with the default of just buying coverage. This is especially because timing does not solve one on the major elements of coverage, accidents. How can you plan when you will be hit by a car & rack up mind blowing medical expenses?

Brian Jones said...

I think this kind of a blog must rank higher in the search engines. I also subscribed to your RSS feed.
content management

Web Design Newzealand

city said...

thanks for share..

muzammal khan said...

advantages were just and sympathetic, and provided a sense of security even to individuals who were fortunate enough to maintain their tasks. bubblegum casting

kavin paker said...

I am overwhelmed by your post with such a nice topic. Usually I visit your blogs and get updated Through the information you include but today’s blog would be the most appreciable.bubblegum casting

Impact Wrench said...

Exchange participants will be paying really money.Best backlinks

Impact Wrench said...

Exiguous item of this explicit positioning entangles pristine instinct car assets, as it is staunch of arrange automobiles moreover loads Weight loss

Impact Wrench said...

I believe that we can save lives and change the world and it starts with the youth. barcelona Seo Service

Impact Wrench said...

I believe that we can save lives and change the world and it starts with the youth Cheap Backlinks

Yasir Khalid said...

She then established The Imani Females Artistic Venture from 1996- 1998, a cinema organization for young ladies of Africa Nice. She wrote several performs for the young organization such as Imani Females Talk Out and The Look for For The Africa Queen which was presented in Southern Front's On The Beachfront Festival. In 2001 she provided as a playwright in property at the Young Individuals Theatre, where she wrote the program Scotian Trip. love to drive car care

Impact Wrench said...

Would love to visit Chernobyl. But as you have said some about the dangers one can face if not equipped properly, need to be very careful while visiting. Thanks for the crucial information. Top Ranking Google